Real estate · Two deals, same rules
How to Compare Rental Deals
Short answer
This is for anyone staring at two listings and wondering which one actually pays. Run both with the same expense rules, then compare monthly cash flow, cash-on-cash return, and break-even rent. Higher rent is not the better deal: a $250,000 house renting for $2,000 loses about $41 a month, while a $180,000 house renting for $1,600 makes about $74 a month and needs $15,400 less cash. The cheaper house only wins if those expense rules are honest.
Last reviewed: November 2026. Made-up numbers to show the process. Educational only, not advice.
Use the same rules on both
Most bad comparisons are not math errors. They are two different sets of assumptions. One listing skips management, the other includes it, and the cheaper-looking deal wins on paper.
Pick one set of rules and apply it to every deal you look at:
- Vacancy 5%, repairs 5%, management 8%, capex 5%. That is 23% of rent before taxes, insurance, and the loan.
- Same down payment percent, same rate, same loan term.
- Taxes from the county site and a real insurance quote, not the seller's numbers.
- Rent from comps you checked yourself.
The Rental Deal Checklist covers what to collect before you run anything.
Two deals, side by side
Both use 20% down, 7% interest, a 30-year loan, and 2% closing costs.
| Line (monthly) | Deal A | Deal B |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $250,000 | $180,000 |
| Rent | $2,000 | $1,600 |
| Vacancy + repairs + mgmt + capex (23%) | -$460 | -$368 |
| Taxes + insurance | -$250 | -$200 |
| Mortgage P&I | -$1,331 | -$958 |
| Cash flow | -$41 | +$74 |
Deal A brings in $400 more rent every month and still loses money. The extra $70,000 of price costs $373 more in loan payment alone, plus higher taxes and a bigger slice for management and capex.
If you skip management and capex the way most flyers do, Deal A shows +$219 and Deal B shows +$282. Both look fine. Only the honest version shows the real gap. More on that in the $250k rental example.
The scorecard
| Number | Deal A | Deal B | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash in (down + closing) | $55,000 | $39,600 | How much of your money is tied up |
| Cash flow per year | -$487 | +$888 | What lands in your account |
| Cash-on-cash return | -0.9% | 2.2% | Return on the cash you put in |
| Break-even rent | $2,053 | $1,504 | How far rent can drop before you pay in |
| Rent as % of price | 0.80% | 0.89% | Quick screen. Closer to 1% is easier to cash flow |
| Cap rate (no loan) | 6.2% | 6.9% | The property's return before financing |
| DSCR (rent / PITI) | 1.27 | 1.38 | What a DSCR lender checks. Many want 1.2 or more |
Deal B has $96 of cushion before it hits break-even rent. Deal A is already below it. If you only look at one row, look at cash flow with honest expenses. Then check cash-on-cash so a deal that needs twice the cash does not sneak through.
Formulas: cash-on-cash, DSCR, cap rate vs cash flow.
Comparison traps
- Comparing rent instead of cash flow. Rent is revenue. You can't spend revenue.
- Different expense rules per deal. If one seller's numbers skip management, add it back before you compare.
- Ignoring cash needed. $15,400 left in your account from buying Deal B is a repair fund or part of the next down payment.
- Counting appreciation as cash flow. It may come, but it does not pay the mortgage in a slow month. See cash flow vs appreciation.
- Price per square foot. Useful for checking comps, useless for picking which deal pays you.
Want other people to check your two deals? Post them with the deal review template.
Compare your two deals
Defaults match the example above. Expense percent covers vacancy, repairs, management, and capex.
The Cash Flow Scout
Compare Rental Deals
Educational only. Not financial advice. Illustration, not a forecast.
For closing costs, appreciation, and loan paydown, run each deal in the Rental Property Calculator.
How to use this calculator
- Set one down payment, one rate, and one expense percent. Every deal has to live under those same rules, or the comparison is a story.
- Enter price, rent, and taxes plus insurance for Deal A and Deal B. Add Deal C or Deal D only when you have another real listing.
- Move the cash flow, appreciation, and risk weights if you care about something other than the 50, 30, and 20 defaults.
- Read Best on the cash flow, cash-on-cash, DSCR, and price rows. The priority score is 0 to 100 for the deal you have selected.
- Copy the link. It stores every deal on the screen. Reset puts the worked example back, not a blank form.
What the numbers mean
- Cash flow
- Monthly rent, minus the expense percent, minus taxes and insurance, minus the loan payment. On the example, Deal A is about -$41 and Deal B is about $74. That gap is the whole point of using one set of rules.
- Cash-on-cash
- Annual cash flow divided by the down payment plus 2 percent closing costs. The letter in the table uses this number and nothing else.
- DSCR
- Rent divided by principal, interest, taxes, and insurance. The example is 1.27 and 1.38. Risk inside the priority score looks at how far this sits below 1.25.
- Appreciation illustration
- 3 percent of price per year. Deal A is $7,500. Deal B is $5,400. It is not a forecast, and it does not change the cash flow math.
- Priority score
- A 0 to 100 mix of cash flow, that appreciation sketch, and DSCR risk. Defaults put Deal A at 62.4 (D) and Deal B at 70.4 (C-). Change the weights and the letters can move.
- Best
- The winning cell on that row. Highest cash flow, cash-on-cash, and DSCR. Lowest price. The word Best is printed in the cell so the color is not the only signal.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best way to compare two rental properties?
Run both with the same expense rules, the same down payment, and the same rate. Then compare monthly cash flow, cash-on-cash return, and break-even rent. The deal with more cushion below break-even is usually the safer one, and a prettier kitchen is not a cushion.
Is the property with higher rent the better deal?
Not always. In the example, $2,000 rent on a $250,000 house loses $41 a month while $1,600 rent on a $180,000 house makes $74. Price drives the loan payment, and the extra rent does not catch it.
Should I compare cap rate or cash-on-cash?
Both, because they answer different questions. Cap rate compares the properties with the loan left out. Cash-on-cash shows what you earn on your own cash with the loan you will actually get.
What expense percentages should I use?
A common starting point is 5% vacancy, 5% repairs, 8% management, and 5% capex, plus real taxes and insurance. Older houses often need more for repairs and capex. Use the same percents on every deal you line up.
What DSCR do lenders want?
Many DSCR lenders look for 1.2 or higher, meaning rent covers the payment, taxes, and insurance by 20%. Requirements vary by lender, so treat 1.2 as a conversation starter, not an approval.
What does the letter grade mean?
The cash-on-cash letter uses the same cuts as the SFR calculator. A is 12 percent or higher, B is 8 percent, C is 5 percent, D is 0 percent or higher, and a negative cash-on-cash is an F. The priority score uses a different 0 to 100 letter. Both are a rule of thumb, not advice.
What is the priority score?
It mixes cash flow, a 3 percent appreciation illustration, and DSCR risk. Default weights are 50, 30, and 20. On the example, Deal A scores 62.4 (D) and Deal B scores 70.4 (C-). The letter uses the same bands as the CFS grade. Illustration, not a forecast.
What does Best mean in the table?
Best marks the winning cell on that row. Cash flow, cash-on-cash, and DSCR reward the highest number. Price rewards the lowest number. A tie marks every deal that shares it. Read the word, not only the color.
Educational only. Not financial advice. Every number here is hypothetical, and taxes, insurance, rents, rates, and lender rules change by market. Get real quotes and comps before you buy.