Skip to main content

FIRE & planning · what if the crash comes first?

Sequence of Returns Risk Calculator

Short answer

Sequence of returns risk is the danger of a crash early in retirement, while you are selling to live. The order of returns matters as much as the average. A 1966 retiree with $1 million in a 60/40 mix, taking $40,000 a year, ran out of money in year 25. Shuffle those exact same returns so the worst years land first and the money lasts only 12 years. Outside cash flow is the cheapest fix: covering $10,000 of a $50,000 budget lifted historical success from 68% to 94%.

Last reviewed: November 19, 2026. Stock and bond returns 1928-2025 from Damodaran (NYU Stern); inflation from BLS CPI-U. Educational estimate, not financial advice.

Sequence of returns risk calculator

This one is for anyone within about ten years of living off a portfolio, or already doing it. Enter your nest egg, your yearly spending, and any income that shows up without selling shares, like rent or a side business. The calculator replays your plan through every real start year since 1928, then takes your chosen start year and reruns the very same returns in worst-first and best-first order so you can watch timing do its damage. Everything is in today's dollars. The link updates as you type, so you can save a plan or send it to your spouse.

The Cash Flow Scout

Sequence of returns risk calculator

Educational only. Not financial advice. Illustration, not a forecast.

Your money
1000005000000
0250000
0150000
Mix and timing
0100
550
19282020
02
030

Back to top

How to use it

  1. Enter the portfolio you will sell from and what you plan to spend each year in today's dollars.
  2. Add outside cash flow: net rent, business profit, a pension. This is the part sequence risk can't touch.
  3. Read the hero number. It is the share of every 30-year (or your length) stretch since 1928 where the money lasted.
  4. Check the worst start year and the max safe spending. If your spending is above that line, history has already shown a way your plan breaks.
  5. Play with the heatmap logic: lower the spending rate a notch or add a little cash flow, and watch which one moves the needle more.

Back to top

How the calculator works

  • Real return = (1 + stock % x S&P 500 return + bond % x 10-year Treasury return - fee) / (1 + CPI inflation) - 1
  • Withdrawal = spending - outside cash flow, taken at the start of each year (never below zero)
  • End balance = (start balance - withdrawal) x (1 + real return)
  • Success rate = start years that never ran short / all start years with a full run of data
  • Worst first / best first = your start year's own returns, sorted low to high or high to low
  • Max safe spending = highest steady spending that survived every historical start

Working in today's dollars keeps the math honest. A $50,000 budget in 1966 dollars and a $50,000 budget in 1995 dollars are not the same life, so spending and cash flow both move with real inflation, year by year, including the brutal 13.3% of 1979. The calculator does not include taxes, Social Security that starts later, or one-off expenses. Treat it as a stress test, not a forecast.

Sources: Damodaran historical returns on stocks, bonds and bills (January 2026 update) and BLS CPI-U, all items, both checked November 19, 2026.

Back to top

Worked example: the 1966 retiree

Picture someone retiring in January 1966 with $1 million (in today's money), 60% stocks and 40% Treasuries, paying 0.2% in fees, and pulling $40,000 a year. That's the 4% rule. Over the next 30 years their mix earned about 3.9% a year after inflation, which sounds fine. The trouble was the first five years: about -1.4% a year in real terms, followed by the 1973-74 bear market and a decade of high inflation.

Same 1966-1995 returns, $40k a yearWhat happened
Actual orderRan out in year 25 (1990)
Worst years firstRan out in year 12
Best years firstEnded with about $2.17 million
Every 30-year start from 1928 to 199665 of 69 lasted (94%)

Now give the same person $10,000 a year of rental income and let them spend $50,000. Their portfolio still has to fund $40,000, so 1966 still breaks. But look at the bigger picture. Without that rent, $50,000 from the portfolio would have survived only 68% of historical starts. With it, 94%. That's the quiet superpower of cash flow: it lets you spend more without asking the stock market for permission. Push the cash flow to $20,000 and every single start year since 1928 lasted.

Back to top

Five ways to shrink sequence risk

  1. Build cash flow before you quit. A paid-off rental or a small business covering 20% to 25% of your spending does more than almost any portfolio tweak. Run the numbers on the rental property calculator.
  2. Keep a cash cushion. One to two years of withdrawals in cash or short Treasuries means you don't sell stocks at the bottom.
  3. Be flexible. Spending 10% less after a down year is boring and works. Try the flex slider.
  4. Watch fees. A 1% advisor fee on a 4% withdrawal plan is a quarter of your income, every year, crash or no crash.
  5. Start lower if you retire early. A 45-year retirement needs a smaller withdrawal rate than a 30-year one. Check yours with the FIRE calculator and the Coast vs Barista FIRE guide.

Back to top

Sequence risk FAQ

What is sequence of returns risk?

It is the risk that bad market years show up early in retirement, while you are selling to pay the bills. Two retirees can earn the exact same average return over 30 years and get opposite results. The one who hits the crash first sells shares cheap, those shares never recover for them, and the portfolio can run dry even after the market comes back.

Why does the order of returns matter if the average is the same?

Because withdrawals turn temporary losses into permanent ones. With no withdrawals, order does not matter at all: 1.2 x 0.8 equals 0.8 x 1.2. Once you take out cash every year, a 30% drop in year one shrinks the base that every later good year compounds on. In this calculator, the 1966 to 1995 returns put in worst-first order run out in year 12; the same returns best-first end above $2 million.

Does the 4% rule protect against sequence risk?

Mostly, and that is exactly what it was built around. Bill Bengen picked the rate that survived the worst historical start, which was 1966. With a 60/40 mix, a 0.2% fee, and this data, a $40,000 withdrawal from $1 million still worked in 65 of 69 thirty-year periods since 1928. The 1966 retiree ran out in year 25. Fees, a heavier bond mix, or a longer retirement push the safe rate lower.

How does cash flow income reduce sequence risk?

Rent, dividends you don't sell, business income, or a pension cover part of the bills, so you sell fewer shares in a down year. In the default example, $10,000 of outside cash flow on $50,000 of spending lifts historical success from 68% to 94%. Same portfolio, same markets; you just stop being a forced seller.

What years were the worst to retire in?

In US data the classic bad starts are 1929, 1937, the mid-1960s, and 1973. The 1966 to 1982 stretch was the killer, because high inflation ate the real value of both stocks and bonds for years. 2000 and 2007 started badly too, but strong later markets rescued most portfolios that held on.

How can I lower sequence of returns risk?

Spend a bit less after down years, keep one to two years of spending in cash or short bonds, build cash flow that does not require selling, and avoid retiring with a withdrawal rate above about 4%. The flex slider shows the effect of trimming spending in years after the portfolio dips below where it started.

Back to top

Educational only. Not financial or tax advice. Results replay past US stock, bond, and inflation data. Future returns, and their order, will be different. No withdrawal rate is guaranteed to last.