Dividends · do your funds own the same stocks?
Dividend ETF Overlap Checker
Short answer
ETF overlap is the share of one fund's money that sits in stocks the other fund also owns. For each shared stock, take the smaller of its two weights and add them up. SCHD and VYM overlap about 23% by weight on their full lists, and they share 78 stocks. Under 20% usually means two funds do different jobs. Over 50% means you're buying the same basket twice and paying two fees for it.
Last reviewed: November 20, 2026. SCHD and VYM figures from fund disclosures, ETF Research Center, and ETF Copilot, November 2026. Educational estimate, not financial advice.
Dividend ETF overlap checker
This one is for anyone holding two or more dividend funds and wondering whether they bought diversification or just bought the same companies twice. Paste each fund's holdings and the checker shows the overlap by weight for every pair, the stocks they share, and your real stake in each company once all the funds are added together. It also blends the yield and fees so you can see what the mix pays and costs. The link updates as you type, holdings included, so you can save it or send it to a friend.
How to use it
- Open each fund's page at its sponsor (Schwab, Vanguard, iShares, State Street) and find the holdings tab. Export the full list if you can.
- Paste the ticker and weight for each holding, one per line. Messy rows copied straight from a table usually work, since the checker grabs the ticker and the last number.
- Enter the dollars you hold in each fund, plus its yield and expense ratio if you want the blended income and fee lines.
- Read the hero number first, then the look-through table. That table is the honest one: it shows what you actually own once every fund is stacked together.
- If one stock passes about 5% of your money, ask whether you meant to make that bet.
How ETF overlap is calculated
- Overlap by weight = sum over shared stocks of the smaller weight
- Overlap by count = shared stocks / stocks in the fund
- Your dollars in a stock = sum over funds of (dollars in fund x stock's weight in that fund)
- Blended yield = total yearly dividends / total dollars
- Blended expense ratio = total yearly fees / total dollars
The count version can fool you. Over 80% of SCHD's 102 stocks also show up in VYM, which sounds like near duplicates. By weight, though, the overlap is only about 23%, because VYM owns around 600 stocks and gives each shared one a much smaller slice. Weight is what moves your money, so the checker leads with weight and shows the count as a side note.
Worked example: SCHD vs VYM
| Measure (Nov 2026) | SCHD | VYM |
|---|---|---|
| Stocks held | 102 | About 600 |
| Expense ratio | 0.06% | 0.04% |
| Dividend yield | About 3.1% | About 2.3% |
| Weight in its top 10 | About 42% | About 26% |
| Overlap by weight (full lists) | About 23%, 78 shared stocks | |
The default preset loads only the 15 top holdings the two funds share, with each fund's real weight. On those lists alone the overlap comes out to 15.1%, which is lower than the 23% you get from the full lists. That gap is the point. Whatever you don't paste is treated as unique, so a short list always flatters you.
Now put $20,000 in each. Procter & Gamble ends up as your largest single stock at about $1,150, roughly 2.9% of the $40,000. You'd collect about $1,080 a year at the blended 2.7% yield and pay about $20 a year in fees. Nothing alarming, frankly. Where it gets interesting is the third and fourth fund. Add a high yield fund that also loves Chevron and Verizon, and those names start creeping toward 5% of your money without you ever buying a single share directly. Run your biggest look-through names through the dividend safety score, then see what a cut would do with the dividend cut stress test.
Sources: ETF Research Center SCHD vs VYM overlap, Schwab SCHD fund page, and ETF Copilot SCHD vs VYM, checked November 20, 2026. Weights change daily, so paste fresh lists for your own check.
How much overlap is too much?
| Overlap by weight | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Under 20% | The funds do different jobs | Keep both if each one has a reason to be there. |
| 20% to 50% | Partly the same basket | Check the look-through table for any stock creeping past 5%. |
| 50% to 80% | Mostly the same fund | Keep the cheaper or simpler one unless the other adds a clear tilt. |
| Over 80% | Near duplicates | You're paying two fees for one portfolio. Pick one. |
These bands are rules of thumb, not law. A growth fund and a high yield fund at 15% overlap can still both lean hard on the same sector, so glance at what the funds hold, not just how much they share. If you want to see the trade-off between the two styles, read dividend growth vs high yield.
ETF overlap FAQ
How do you calculate ETF overlap?
For every stock both funds hold, take the smaller of its two weights, then add those up. If Fund A holds Coca-Cola at 4.3% and Fund B holds it at 1.4%, that stock adds 1.4 points of overlap. The total tells you how much of one fund you already own through the other. 0% means no shared stocks and 100% means the same fund twice.
How much do SCHD and VYM overlap?
About 23% by weight on the full holdings lists, according to ETF Research Center in November 2026. SCHD held 102 stocks and VYM roughly 600, with 78 in both. The overlap looks small because VYM spreads its money across so many names, yet most of SCHD's companies also sit inside VYM.
What is a good overlap percentage between two ETFs?
There is no official line, but a common rule of thumb is that under about 20% means the funds do different jobs, 20% to 50% deserves a second look, and over 50% means you are mostly buying the same basket twice. Two broad U.S. index funds can overlap 80% or more.
Is ETF overlap bad?
Not by itself. Overlap only hurts when it hides a concentration you did not choose, like one bank or one oil company turning out to be 6% of your money, or when you pay a high fee for a fund that mostly copies a cheap one. The look-through table shows whether either is happening.
Where do I find an ETF's holdings?
On the fund company's own page. Schwab, Vanguard, iShares, and State Street all post holdings, usually daily or monthly, and most let you export the full list. Paste the ticker and weight columns. Top-10 lists work, but they understate overlap because everything you leave out counts as unique.
Does overlap change my dividend income?
Not directly. Your income depends on each fund's yield and how much you put in. Overlap changes the risk behind that income: if a shared company cuts its dividend, every fund that holds it feels the cut at once.
Educational only. Not financial or tax advice. Results come from the holdings you paste, and fund weights change every day. Overlap measures shared holdings, not future returns or dividend safety.