Skip to main content

Real estate · Price the offer first

Max Offer Calculator for Rental Property

Short answer

This works backward from the returns you want to the highest price you should pay, for anyone who falls for a listing before they run it. A $180,000 house renting for $1,800 (it passes the 1% rule) with 25% down at 7% makes only $169 a month at list. To hit $200 a month, 8% cash-on-cash, a 1.25 DSCR, and a 7% cap rate, your max offer is $158,219. That is 88% of list, or $21,781 under the asking price. Grade D, and the seller does not have to say yes.

Last reviewed: November 2026. Example rates, not offers. Educational only, not financial advice.

Rental property max offer calculator

Enter the listing, the loan, and the returns you need. The calculator solves the highest price that meets each target and uses the lowest one as your offer. The 1% rule price and the 70% rule price sit beside that offer as checks. They do not change it. Nothing you type is saved or sent anywhere.

The listing and loan
Expenses
Your targets

The Cash Flow Scout

Max offer calculator

Illustration, not a forecast. Educational only, not financial advice.

Max offer

$158,219

Set by 8% cash-on-cash

Verdict

List price grade

Growth is 0, so each year matches year-1 cash flow at the max offer.

The lowest target sets the offer. The 1% rule and the 70% rule are checks.

Ceiling for each rule

What moves the ceiling

Offer ladder

Scenarios

Fixed-rate loan, month 1 numbers. Income taxes, depreciation, rent growth, and appreciation are not modeled. Example rate, not an offer. Illustration, not a forecast.

Back to top

How to use the max offer calculator

  1. Set your targets first. Decide the cash flow and cash-on-cash you need before the listing gets cute. Set a percent or DSCR target to 0 to ignore it. Clear the cash flow box to ignore that one.
  2. Enter the listing with rent from real comps. The guide on pulling rent comps shows how.
  3. Enter the loan from a real quote: down payment, rate, and closing costs. A guessed rate makes a guessed offer.
  4. Read the max offer and which target set it. That target is the one to work on, not the one that already looks fine.
  5. Use the offer ladder to see what each price does, then copy the link for your agent or partner.
  6. Check the screens. Read the 1% rule price and the 70% rule price. Drag the asking-price slider. The words say Over the ceiling or Under the ceiling, in dollars and as a percent of the asking price.

Back to top

What the numbers mean

Max offer
The lowest price that still meets every target you left on. On the defaults that is $158,219, set by 8% cash-on-cash. Pay more than that and one of your targets is already gone.
Binding constraint
The target with the lowest price. Cash flow, cash-on-cash, DSCR, and cap rate are all solved. The lowest one sets the offer, and the others are just watching.
1% rule price
Monthly rent divided by 0.01. A screen, not the offer. The longer note is does the 1% rule still work.
70% rule price
After-repair value times 0.70, minus rehab. When rehab is $0 and the after-repair value equals the asking price, this is 70% of that price. It does not change the max offer.
Gap
Asking price minus the max offer. Gap percent divides that gap by the asking price. Over the ceiling means the list is higher. Under the ceiling means the list is at or below the offer.
Grade
How far the asking price sits above your max offer. A is at or under. F is more than 20% over. The letter follows that gap, not how much you like the street.
Cash flow, cash-on-cash, DSCR, cap rate
Month-1 results at the asking price. DSCR is net operating income divided by the loan payment. Run a specific loan in the DSCR loan calculator.

Back to top

Worked example: a 1% rule house that is still overpriced

The listing is $180,000 and rents for $1,800, exactly 1% of the price. Vacancy, repairs, capex, and management take 25% of rent, leaving $1,350 a month. Minus $1,600 a year of insurance, that is $14,600 a year before property tax and the loan.

At list: 1% tax is $1,800, so net operating income is $12,800 and the cap rate is 7.1%. The $135,000 loan at 7% costs $898 a month, or $10,778 a year. That leaves $169 a month. Cash in is $45,000 down plus $5,400 closing, so cash-on-cash is 4.0%. DSCR is 1.19.

Working backward: each $1,000 off the price saves about $6 a month in loan payment and tax, and $280 of cash in. To reach 8% cash-on-cash the price has to drop to $158,219. At that price the house makes $295 a month, DSCR is 1.37, and you need $44,301 to close.

So the honest offer is about $158,000. The seller may say no. That is fine. The math tells you when to walk.

Back to top

What the grade means

GradeList price compared with your max offer
AAt or under your max offer. The list price already meets every target.
BUp to 5% over. A normal negotiation can close the gap.
C5% to 10% over. Offer your number and be ready to walk.
D10% to 20% over. Needs a big cut, more rent, or a cheaper loan.
FMore than 20% over. Not a cash flow deal at these numbers.

Back to top

What raises your max offer

  • Self-managing. Dropping the 10% manager in the example raises the max offer from $158,219 to $181,627, above list. Grade A.
  • A cheaper loan. At 6% instead of 7% the max offer is $169,061. Grade C.
  • A lower target. Accepting 6% cash-on-cash instead of 8% raises it to $168,441.
  • More rent. At list price the deal meets every target at $2,023 a month. Real comps decide if that is possible, not hope.

Once you have a price, run the full deal in the SFR rental calculator or line it up against other listings with compare rental deals.

Back to top

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate the max offer on a rental property?

Pick the returns you need, then work backward. Rent minus vacancy, repairs, capex, and management, minus insurance, is the income the price has to support. Property tax, the loan payment, and your cash in all grow with the price, so each target gives one highest price. The lowest of those prices is your max offer. In the default deal that is $158,219, set by the 8% cash-on-cash target.

What is a good cash-on-cash target for a max offer?

Many small landlords use 8% to 10% for a long-term rental. Some accept 5% to 6% in a fast-growing area where they expect rent and value growth. Dropping the target from 8% to 6% in the default deal raises the max offer from $158,219 to $168,441. Pick the number before you look at listings, not after you fall for one.

Does the 1% rule still give a good offer price?

Not on its own at 7% rates. The default house rents for exactly 1% of its $180,000 price and still makes only $169 a month and 4.0% cash-on-cash at list with a manager. The 1% rule price here is monthly rent divided by 0.01, which is $180,000 on the default. Use it to screen listings, then use this calculator to price the offer.

Why does property tax change when I change the price?

Many counties reassess at the sale price, so tax is entered as a percent of price. That way a lower offer also lowers the tax the deal has to carry. If your county does not reassess on sale, set the percent so it matches the current bill at your price.

What DSCR do lenders want?

DSCR (debt service coverage ratio) is net operating income divided by the loan payment. Most DSCR lenders want at least 1.0 to 1.25, and the best rates usually start around 1.25. The default deal is 1.19 at list and 1.37 at the max offer. The DSCR loan calculator checks a specific loan.

Can I share my numbers with a partner or agent?

Yes. Copy link puts every changed input in the URL, so your partner, agent, or lender opens the same deal. An older link that still lists every field works too. Nothing is saved on our server.

What are the 1% rule price and the 70% rule price?

The 1% rule price is monthly rent divided by 0.01. The 70% rule price is after-repair value times 0.70, minus rehab. On the default, rent of $1,800 gives a 1% price of $180,000. Rehab is $0 and the after-repair value starts at the asking price, so the 70% rule is $126,000. Both are checks. They do not change the max offer.

What does over the ceiling mean?

The gap is the asking price minus the max offer. Gap percent is that gap divided by the asking price. Over the ceiling means the asking price is higher than the max offer. Under the ceiling means the asking price is equal to or lower than the max offer. The default list is about $21,781 over, or 12.1% of asking. Drag the asking-price slider to watch it move.

Which target sets the max offer?

Every target you leave on gets its own highest price. The lowest of those prices sets the offer. On the defaults the four ceilings are about $174,592 for $200 a month, $158,219 for 8% cash-on-cash, $172,075 for a 1.25 DSCR, and $182,500 for a 7% cap rate. Cash-on-cash is the lowest, so it binds. The 1% and 70% prices are shown on the same chart and do not bind.

Educational only. Not financial advice. Rents, values, and rates can move against you, and a seller who says no is not a math error. Example rates, not offers.