Skip to main content

Real estate · Deal analysis

Rental Deal Checklist: 20 Checks Before You Buy

Short answer

Before you run any rental numbers, collect 20 things: your real purchase costs, three rent comps, property taxes at your price, a real insurance quote, reserves for vacancy, repairs, capex, and management, and your actual loan terms. Skip them and the deal looks better than it is. In the example below, a $160,000 house shows +$303 a month on the seller's numbers and +$75 a month once every item on this list is checked.

Last reviewed: November 2026. Made-up numbers to show the process. Educational only, not advice.

The 20-item checklist

Tick each one off as you get a real number. Print this page or save it to your phone before a showing.

Purchase (5)

Income (3)

Expenses (8)

Financing (3)

Area (1)

Checked items stay in this browser only.

Back to top

Flyer numbers vs checked numbers

Same $160,000 house. 20% down, 7% interest, 30-year loan. Rent $1,450, the lowest of three comps.

Line (monthly)FlyerChecked
Rent$1,450$1,450
Vacancy + repairs-$145 (10%)-$145 (10%)
Capex + management$0-$189 (13%)
Taxes + insurance-$150 (seller's tax bill)-$190 (reassessed tax + real quote)
Mortgage P&I-$852-$852
Cash flow+$303+$75

The flyer is off by $228 a month, or about $2,700 a year. Nothing on it was a lie. It just left out four items from the list.

With the checked numbers you put in $36,000 (20% down plus 2.5% closing) and earn about $900 a year. That is 2.5% cash-on-cash. Break-even rent is $1,353, so rent can drop $97 before you pay in. Whether that is good enough is your call. At least now it is a real number.

Want to see two deals run this way side by side? Read how to compare rental deals or the $250k rental example.

Back to top

Walk-away rules

Decide these before you fall in love with a kitchen. Our rules of thumb, not law:

  • Negative cash flow with checked numbers. Renegotiate the price or pass. Hoping for appreciation is a bet, not a plan. See cash flow vs appreciation.
  • Break-even rent above your lowest comp. One bad lease and you are paying in.
  • Less than 6 months of payments left in reserve after closing. In the example, that is about $6,250 (principal, interest, taxes, insurance).
  • A roof or HVAC near end of life that the price ignores. Ask for a credit or take the cost off your offer.
  • Seller numbers you cannot check. No leases, no utility bills, no tax record. Assume the worst until proven otherwise.

Not sure? Post the deal with the deal review template and get a second set of eyes.

Back to top

Quick screen calculator

Defaults match the checked example. Expense percent covers vacancy, repairs, capex, and management.

Quick screen
020000
020

For appreciation, loan paydown, and rehab, run the full deal in the Rental Property Calculator or the free CFS Rental Calculator app on Google Play.

Back to top

FAQ

What should I check before buying a rental property?

Your real purchase and closing costs, the age of the roof and HVAC, three rent comps, property taxes at your price, an insurance quote, reserves for vacancy, repairs, capex, and management, your loan terms, and where the area is headed. The checklist above has all 20.

What percentage of rent should I set aside for expenses?

A common starting point is 23% of rent: 5% vacancy, 5% repairs, 5% capex, and 8% management. Taxes, insurance, and the loan are on top of that. Older houses usually need more for repairs and capex. The CapEx reserve calculator prices the roof, HVAC, and the other big items from cost and age, then adds a vacancy and turnover reserve.

Why are property taxes on the listing often wrong?

The listing shows what the seller pays. Many counties reassess the property after a sale, so your bill can be higher. Look up the rate on the county site and apply it to your price.

How much cash should I keep in reserve for a rental?

Many investors keep at least 6 months of principal, interest, taxes, and insurance per property. Some lenders require a set amount of reserves to approve the loan.

Should I count management if I manage the property myself?

Yes. Self-managing saves the fee but costs your time, and you may hire a manager later. If the deal only works without management, it is a thin deal.

Educational only. Not financial advice. All numbers are hypothetical. Taxes, insurance, rents, rates, and lender rules vary by market and change over time. Get real quotes and comps before you buy.