Crypto · same dollars, three income checks
Crypto vs Dividends vs Rental
Short answer
On $50,000 in each sleeve, rental income totals $40,123.58 over 10 years, the highest of the three. In a bad year, rental still pays $218.75 a month, the largest bad-year check. This is for someone comparing cash income only. Principal value is out of scope, and the rental number needs tenants and repairs the others do not. Last reviewed: November 2026. Educational only. Not financial advice.
Last reviewed: November 2026. Illustration, not a forecast.
Cash flow comparison
Same $50,000, three jobs. This page is for someone asking what each sleeve puts in your pocket, not what the principal might be worth later. Crypto yield, dividend yield, and rental cash-on-cash each get a growth rate and a bad-year hit. One of them calls you about a leaking sink. The other two do not.
How to use this comparison
- Leave the amount at $50,000 or type the cash you would actually put into one sleeve.
- Type the income yield you were offered, not the yield in an ad you liked.
- Set growth to 0 if you do not want the check to rise. Crypto starts there on purpose.
- Read the bad-year column before you treat year 10 as a plan.
- Copy the link if you want the same inputs again. The link stores the boxes, not a forecast.
What the numbers mean
- Year 1 monthly
- Amount times yield, divided by 12. Crypto shows $166.67, dividends $145.83, rental $291.67.
- Year 10 monthly
- Year-1 monthly times one plus growth, raised to the ninth power. Crypto stays $166.67. Dividends show $246.38. Rental shows $380.56.
- Bad year
- Year-1 monthly times one minus the hit. Crypto $66.67, dividends $131.25, rental $218.75.
- N-year total
- Each year's income added, with growth, for the number of years in the box. Defaults: $20,000.00, $23,066.39, and $40,123.58. Principal is not in the sum.
Worked example: $50,000 in each
$50,000 at 4% is $2,000 a year. Divided by 12, the crypto check shows $166.67 a month. Growth is 0, so year 10 is the same $166.67. Ten years of $2,000 is $20,000.00. A 60% bad-year hit leaves $66.67 a month. The rate did not get braver. It just sat there.
Dividends use 3.5%. That is $1,750 a year, and the page shows $145.83 a month in year 1. Growth of 6% a year puts year 10 at $246.38 a month. The 10-year total is $23,066.39. A 10% hit on the first year's check is $131.25. Steady growth is a math setting here, not a board that promised you a raise.
Rental cash-on-cash starts at 7%. Cash-on-cash means yearly cash left after expenses, divided by the cash you put in. On $50,000 that is $3,500 a year, shown as $291.67 a month. Growth of 3% puts year 10 at $380.56. The 10-year total is $40,123.58. A 25% hit leaves $218.75, still the largest bad-year monthly of the three.
Rental has the highest 10-year total, $40,123.58. Rental has the steadiest bad year, at $218.75 a month. The rental number needs work (tenants, repairs) the others do not. Change one box at a time if you want to see which story was doing the heavy lifting.
What a bad year means
A bad year here is a pay cut, not a crystal ball. The model takes year-1 monthly income and multiplies by one minus the hit. It does not replay a historical crash, and it does not sell the principal. Crypto's 60% hit is harsh on purpose. Reward rates move, platforms fail, and a yield that was 4% last Tuesday can be a rounding error by Friday.
Dividends at a 10% hit are the mild sketch: a cut, not a wipeout. Plenty of payers freeze the dividend instead, which would be a different picture than 6% growth every year. If you want that picture, set dividend growth to 0 and raise the hit. The page will not be offended.
Rental's 25% hit is a stand-in for vacancy, a repair, or a month of concessions. It is not a full stress test. A roof does not care that your spreadsheet used 25%. The steadiest bad year on the default chart is still rental, at $218.75, because the starting check was larger. A smaller percent cut on a smaller check can lose the dollar comparison. Read the dollars.
The grouped bars put year 1, year 10, and the bad year side by side. Year 10 uses nine years of growth even if you shorten the Years box. The line chart, and the total, follow the Years box. If those two disagree, you asked for a short total and a year-10 peek at the same time.
What this leaves out
Principal value is out of scope. The $50,000 does not grow, shrink, or get a new appraisal. A coin can drop 80% while this page still prints $166.67. A house can be worth more than you paid and still have a broken dryer. Share prices are someone else's chart. This one is the income check only.
Taxes are out too. Staking rewards, qualified dividends, and rental cash are not the same kind of income at filing time. A higher pre-tax total can lose after the bill. This comparison will not pretend to be a return. If the dollars are for spending, run the after-tax number with someone who signs returns.
Work is the quiet line. Rental income in this sketch needs tenants, repairs, and time. Dividend cash and a staking reward do not text you at 9 p.m. That does not make them safe. It makes them a different job. Safe is a word this page will not hand out.
Example rates, not offers. Nothing here is a promise that the next 10 years will resemble the boxes. Illustration, not a forecast. Educational only. Not financial advice.
Comparison FAQ
Which pays more cash flow?
On the default $50,000 in each sleeve, rental income totals $40,123.58 over 10 years. Dividends total $23,066.39. Crypto totals $20,000.00 because its growth box starts at 0. Those are illustrations of the yields you type, not a ranking of asset classes and not an offer.
Why is crypto income growth set to 0?
The example does not assume the reward rate climbs on a schedule. Year 1 and year 10 both show $166.67 a month until you type a growth rate. Dividend growth starts at 6% and rental income growth starts at 3%. Change any of them. A zero is an input, not a claim that crypto income never grows.
What is a bad-year income hit?
A percent cut to year-1 monthly income. Crypto starts at a 60% hit, so $166.67 becomes $66.67. Dividends take 10% and land at $131.25. Rental takes 25% and lands at $218.75. It is a pay cut in the model, not a price crash and not a forecast of next year.
Does this include price changes?
No. The totals are income only. A coin price, a share price, and a house price are out of scope. Year 10 on the chart is the income check after growth, not the value of the principal. If the price goes to zero, the income story can die with it, and this page will not show that death.
Why does the rental number need work?
Cash-on-cash already tries to be the cash left after expenses, divided by the cash you put in. The 7% example still assumes someone finds tenants, fixes what breaks, and sits through vacancy. Crypto rewards and dividend deposits do not call you about a leaking sink. The larger rental total is not free money.
Are these yields promises?
No. 4%, 3.5%, and 7% are example rates so the picture has a starting point. Get a real quote, a real distribution policy, and a real rent roll. Nothing here is a promise of return. Educational only. Not financial advice.
Educational only. Not financial advice. Yields are examples, not offers. Income illustrations are not a forecast, and principal value is out of scope. The rental figure still needs tenants and repairs.