Real estate · Worked example
Analyzing a $250k Rental
Short answer
A $250,000 house renting for $1,800 with 20% down at 7% clears about $39 a month if you skip management and big repairs. Budget 8% for management and 5% for capital expenses and it loses about $195 a month. It needs roughly $2,050 rent to break even honestly. Buy it at $220,000 and get $1,950 rent and it makes about $81 a month, which is still thin, and many people pass. The full stack behind those lines is rental property cash flow.
Last reviewed: November 2026. Made-up numbers to show the process. Educational only, not advice.
The inputs
The inputs are the price, the down payment, and rent taken from comps rather than the seller's hope. Everything after this is just subtraction, which is less fun than a showing and more useful.
| Input | Value | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $250,000 | A typical starter single-family price in many metros |
| Down payment | 20% ($50,000) | Common investor loan minimum |
| Closing costs | $5,000 | About 2% of price |
| Loan | $200,000 at 7%, 30 years | Investor rates usually run above owner-occupied rates |
| Rent | $1,800 / month | From comps, not the seller's number |
| Taxes + insurance | $250 / month | Check the county site and get a real quote |
| Vacancy | 5% of rent | About 18 empty days a year |
| Repairs | 5% of rent | Small fixes: faucets, doors, a dead water heater element |
Total cash in: $55,000 (down payment plus closing). Picture an example buyer named Andre opening the escrow statement and finding that cash already gone, before a single rent check exists.
The math, line by line
The flyer version of the math is the short table, and it stops before management and big repairs. The mortgage is doing most of the eating.
| Line | Monthly |
|---|---|
| Rent | $1,800 |
| Vacancy (5%) | -$90 |
| Repairs (5%) | -$90 |
| Taxes + insurance | -$250 |
| Mortgage P&I ($200k, 7%, 30 yr) | -$1,331 |
| Cash flow | +$39 |
$39 a month is $473 a year on $55,000 of cash. Cash-on-cash return is about 0.9%. A savings account beats that with zero tenants, which is a humbling sentence to read out loud.
The full method behind each line is in how to calculate rental property cash flow. The percent itself is how to calculate cash-on-cash return, and you can drop the same lines into the cash-on-cash calculator.
Flyer version vs honest version
The flyer version stops early, and the honest version keeps going until management and capex are in the pile. You will pay both eventually, even if the flyer pretends you will not.
| Line | Flyer version | Honest version |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | $1,800 | $1,800 |
| Vacancy + repairs (10%) | -$180 | -$180 |
| Taxes + insurance | -$250 | -$250 |
| Management (8%) | $0 | -$144 |
| Capex reserve (5%): roof, HVAC, flooring | $0 | -$90 |
| Mortgage P&I | -$1,331 | -$1,331 |
| Cash flow | +$39 | -$195 |
Self-managing saves the $144, but your time is not free, and you may not self-manage forever. Capex is not optional. A $9,000 HVAC replacement every 15 years is $50 a month whether you save for it or not. The furnace does not care that you labeled the line optional.
Break-even rent: about $1,756 on the flyer version and about $2,053 on the honest version.
What it takes to work
One change at a time shows which lever actually moves the honest number. Price does more work than a hopeful rent bump, which is annoying and also useful.
| Change | Flyer cash flow | Honest cash flow |
|---|---|---|
| Nothing (base case) | +$39 | -$195 |
| Rate drops to 6% | +$171 | -$63 |
| Rent is $1,950 | +$174 | -$79 |
| Price is $220,000 | +$199 | -$35 |
| $220,000 price and $1,950 rent | n/a | +$81 |
Price is the biggest lever because it shrinks the loan and the cash you put in. At $220,000 and $1,950 rent you put in $49,000 and make about $967 a year. That is roughly 2% cash-on-cash before any appreciation or loan paydown.
So what do you do with a deal like this? None of the choices below promises a rising price. They only describe the cash.
- Pass if you need cash flow now. There are other houses.
- Offer lower using the honest table. Sellers can argue with opinions, not with a mortgage payment.
- Buy it on purpose for appreciation only if you can carry a small loss for years. See cash flow vs appreciation.
Got two deals to compare? Put them side by side in Compare Rental Deals. Want someone to poke holes in yours? Use the deal review template.
Run your own numbers
The defaults match the honest version above, so the first result should look like that negative month. Change any field after that, and do not change the story until the number moves.
For the full version with closing costs and appreciation, use the Rental Property Calculator.
FAQ
The questions are the ones people ask after the flyer says the house works. The honest column is the one that answers them.
Does a $250,000 rental cash flow?
At $1,800 rent, 20% down, and 7% interest, barely. It shows about +$39 a month before management and capex and about -$195 after. It depends on the rent-to-price ratio in your market, not on how nice the kitchen looked on a Saturday.
What rent does a $250k rental need to break even?
With 20% down at 7%, about $1,756 a month on a bare-bones budget and about $2,053 once you add 8% management and 5% capex. The second figure is the one that still works if you hire the work out.
Should I include property management if I self-manage?
Yes, at least in the analysis. It shows whether the deal still works if you move, get busy, or hire it out later. Your Saturday is not a permanent business model.
What fixes a thin rental deal fastest?
A lower purchase price. It cuts the loan payment and the cash you put in at the same time. Higher rent and lower rates help, and they help less per dollar than the price cut.
Is negative cash flow ever OK?
Only if you chose it on purpose, can cover the loss from your paycheck for years, and are making an appreciation bet in that area. It is a bet, not income. Call it a bet at the kitchen table, before the offer, not after the first repair.
Educational only. Not financial advice. All numbers are hypothetical. Taxes, insurance, rents, and rates vary by market and change over time. Get real quotes and comps before you buy.