1031 Exchange Into Multifamily: Does It Raise Your Cash Flow?
A common plan goes like this. Buy a few houses, let them grow equity, then sell them and roll the money into a fourplex or small apartment building with a 1031 exchange so you pay no tax yet. The tax part can work. The cash flow part depends on the new loan. Here are example numbers on trading two houses for a fourplex, and a calculator for your own. Last reviewed: November 2026.
Short answer
A 1031 exchange defers the tax. It does not create cash flow by itself. In our example, selling two houses with a $172,000 gain would cost about $40,400 in tax without an exchange.
Rolled into a $560,000 fourplex at 7.25%, cash flow goes from $700 to $869 a month. Paying off the two houses instead would make about $1,600 a month.
The rules that kill most exchanges are the clock (45 days to name, 180 to close) and boot (cash or debt you do not replace, which is taxed).
Updated November 17, 2026 by The Cash Flow Scout. Rules checked against IRS guidance on like-kind exchanges; rates checked against Freddie Mac.
How does a 1031 exchange work?
Section 1031 lets you sell investment real estate and put off the tax on the gain if you buy other investment real estate with the money. The tax is deferred, not erased. Your old low basis carries into the new property.
Miss the paperwork and the deferral dies even if the fourplex is a good buy. The clock is the part people underestimate.
- A qualified intermediary holds the money. If the sale cash touches your bank account, the exchange is dead. Set this up before you close the sale. Fees often run $1,000 to $1,500.
- 45 days to name the replacement in writing, counted from the day the old property closes.
- 180 days to close on the replacement, counted from the same day.
- Buy at least as much as you sold and reinvest all the cash. Any cash you keep, or loan balance you do not replace with new debt or cash, is taxable. That leftover is called boot.
- Like-kind is broad. Any US investment real estate counts, so two houses into one fourplex is fine. Your home and fix-and-flips do not count.
What are the 1031 exchange rules?
A 1031 exchange works when you sell investment real estate, a qualified intermediary holds the cash, you name replacements within 45 days, close within 180 days, and buy at least as much as you sold with all the equity reinvested. Break any one of those and part or all of the gain is taxed.
| Rule | What it means | Where people trip |
|---|---|---|
| Investment or business property only | Rentals, land, and commercial buildings held to invest. Since 2018, real estate only. | Your home and flips do not qualify. |
| Qualified intermediary | A third party holds the sale money and buys the new property. | Cash touching your account ends the deferral. |
| 45-day identification | Name replacements in writing by midnight of day 45. | No extension for weekends or holidays. |
| 180-day closing | Close by day 180 or your tax return due date, whichever comes first. | A fall sale needs an extension to keep all 180 days. |
| 3-property or 200% rule | Name up to 3 properties, or more if their total is no more than 200% of what you sold. | Naming 5 cheap backups can break the 200% cap. |
| Equal or greater value and debt | Buy at least the net sale price and replace the old loan with new debt or cash. | Any shortfall is boot and is taxed. |
| Same taxpayer | The name on the sale must be the name on the purchase. | Selling personally, then buying in a new LLC with partners. |
| Related parties | Swaps with family or your own entities need both sides to hold 2 years. | Buying from a relative usually fails. |
| Report it | File Form 8824 with the return for the year of the sale. | Skipping the form invites the question. |
A single-member LLC that is ignored for tax counts as you, so selling in your name and buying in that LLC is usually fine. A multi-member LLC is a partnership, which is a different taxpayer. If you own a rental 50/50 with a partner, decide who exchanges what before the listing goes live. Sources: IRS like-kind exchanges fact sheet and About Form 8824.
How much tax does a 1031 exchange defer?
Without an exchange, this example owes about $40,400, which is about 14% of the equity, before anything new is bought. Higher earners can owe more.
Example only, not a recommendation. Say an owner named Casey has two single-family rentals worth $200,000 each. Casey is an example. Casey paid $260,000 for both combined and took $60,000 of depreciation over the years, so the adjusted basis is $200,000. Casey still owes $90,000 on the two loans. Selling costs 7%.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price, both houses | $400,000 |
| Selling costs (7%) | -$28,000 |
| Loan payoff | -$90,000 |
| Cash equity out | $282,000 |
| Taxable gain ($372,000 net minus $200,000 basis) | $172,000 |
| Depreciation recapture ($60,000 at 25%) | $15,000 |
| Capital gains tax ($112,000 at 15%) | $16,800 |
| State tax (5% assumed) | $8,600 |
| Tax if you sell without a 1031 | $40,400 |
That is about 14% of the equity gone before you buy anything. Higher earners can owe 20% capital gains plus the 3.8% net investment income tax, so the bill can be bigger. To defer all of it you would buy at least $372,000 of property and put all $282,000 of equity in. Keeping a little cash "just in case" is how boot shows up.
Does a 1031 into multifamily raise cash flow?
The exchange beats paying the tax, and it barely beats keeping the houses. Paying the houses off wins on monthly cash if that is the goal.
Today the two houses rent for $1,500 each. Repairs, vacancy, and management take 30%, tax and insurance run $500 a month, and the two old loans cost $900 a month. That leaves $700 a month.
The replacement is a $560,000 fourplex renting at $1,300 a unit. You put in $280,500 (equity minus a $1,500 intermediary fee), spend 3% on closing costs, and borrow $296,300 at 7.25% for 30 years. (Freddie Mac's average 30-year rate was 7.11% on November 12, 2026, and investor loans on 2 to 4 units usually price higher, so 7.25% is a friendly assumption, not a stretch.) Same 30% for repairs, vacancy, and management. Tax and insurance are $750.
| Per month | Keep the houses | 1031 into fourplex | Pay the tax, then buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent | $3,000 | $5,200 | $5,200 |
| Repairs, vacancy, management (30%) | -$900 | -$1,560 | -$1,560 |
| Tax and insurance | -$500 | -$750 | -$750 |
| Loan payment | -$900 | -$2,021 | -$2,297 |
| Cash flow | $700 | $869 | $593 |
The exchange beats paying the tax by $276 a month, because the $40,400 stays working instead of going to the IRS. The trade itself only adds $169 a month over keeping the houses. You took on a $296,300 loan at 7.25% to get that. That is a lot of new debt for a modest raise.
Now compare the boring option. Pay off the last $90,000 on the two houses and they make about $1,600 a month with no debt. If cash flow is the goal, that wins. The fourplex wins on size: you control $560,000 of property instead of $400,000, so rent growth and appreciation work on a bigger base. See pay off your rental or buy another one for that trade-off. The multifamily calculator is where the fourplex gets a full underwriting, and rental property cash flow is the monthly formula underneath it.
The fourplex needs about $1,240 a unit just to match the $700 the houses make today. Check real rent comps before you count on more.
1031 exchange cash flow calculator
Type in your own properties and a real listing. Tax rates here are rough. Your CPA has the real ones. Nothing is saved or sent anywhere.
Open the multifamily calculator to carry this price, rent, and loan into a full underwriting. The sketch above is not the loan commitment.
A 30-year fixed loan is assumed. Depreciation recapture is taxed at up to 25%, and the calculator uses 25%. It ignores the 3.8% net investment income tax and any loss on the sale.
When a 1031 into multifamily makes sense
It makes sense when you have a real gain, you want to keep owning real estate, and the new property pays more after the new loan. Tax saved on a worse building is not a win.
- You have a big gain and want to keep owning real estate. Deferring $40,000 of tax is real money working for you.
- The new property makes more than the old ones after the new loan. Run the calculator. If the answer is barely positive, you are taking on more debt for little extra income.
- Your houses are tired or spread out. One roof, one insurance policy, and one location can be easier to run than three houses across town.
- You plan to hold until you die. Under current law, heirs usually get a stepped-up basis, so the deferred tax may never be paid. Laws can change.
When to skip it
Skip it when the old loans are cheap and nearly gone, or when you cannot find a replacement you would buy anyway inside 45 days. Rushing to save tax is how people buy the wrong building.
- Your old loans are at 3% to 4.5% and nearly paid off. Trading them for a large 7% loan can cut your cash flow even with the tax saved.
- You cannot find a replacement you would buy anyway inside 45 days. Rushing into a bad deal to save tax is how people lose more than the tax.
- You want cash out to live on. Any cash you take is taxed, so a 1031 does not fund retirement directly.
- The gain is small. A $10,000 tax bill may not be worth the deadlines, fees, and pressure.
Run the new property through the stress test before you name it. A fourplex with one bad tenant still has three paying.
Frequently asked questions
Does a 1031 exchange increase cash flow?
Not by itself. It keeps more of your equity working, which helps. In the example, trading two houses for a fourplex raised cash flow from $700 to $869 a month, but paying off the two houses instead would make about $1,600 a month.
How much tax does a 1031 exchange save?
It defers the tax. It does not erase it. In the example, selling two houses with a $172,000 gain would cost about $40,400 in federal and state tax without an exchange. That bill comes back later unless the basis steps up under rules that can change.
Can I 1031 two single-family rentals into one fourplex?
Yes. Any US investment real estate is like-kind, so two houses into one fourplex can qualify. You need to buy at least as much as you sold, reinvest all the cash, and use a qualified intermediary.
What are the 1031 exchange deadlines?
You have 45 days after the sale closes to name replacement properties in writing, and 180 days to close on them, or your tax return due date if that comes first. The deadlines do not extend for weekends or holidays. Miss either one and the deferral is gone.
How many properties can I identify in a 1031 exchange?
Most investors use the 3-property rule: name up to three properties of any value and buy one or more. The 200% rule lets you name more than three if their total value is no more than twice what you sold. The 95% rule allows any number, but you must actually buy 95% of the value named.
What if my sale closes late in the year?
Watch the tax return deadline. Sell on November 1 and day 180 lands in late April, after the usual April 15 due date. File an extension and you keep the full 180 days. Forget it and the exchange period ends on April 15.
How do I report a 1031 exchange to the IRS?
On Form 8824, Like-Kind Exchanges, filed with your return for the year you sold the old property. It shows the dates, the properties, any boot, and the deferred gain that carries into the new basis. Your qualified intermediary statement and closing statements are the backup.
Can I do a 1031 exchange on a rental I own with a partner?
If you each hold title directly, each owner can usually exchange their own share. If the property is owned by an LLC or partnership, the entity has to do the exchange. Talk to a CPA before you list, not after the closing statement is printed.
Next steps
Run the new loan before you fall in love with the tax deferral. $169 a month is not a reason to take on $296,300 by itself.
Run the new deal Compare paying off
Thinking about trading up? Post your current rents, loan balances, and the property you are eyeing on the discussion board or in Discord before you list. A CPA and a qualified intermediary still have to bless the real exchange.
Educational only. Not tax, legal, lending, or financial advice. Hypothetical examples are labeled. Tax rates and 1031 rules shown are simplified; work with a CPA and a qualified intermediary. Run your own numbers.