Skip to main content

Pay Off Your Rental or Buy Another One?

Paying off a rental is boring and certain, and buying another door is exciting and uncertain. Compare them with the cash each choice puts in your pocket, not with how the second house feels at the open house. For a home loan, the mortgage payoff calculator shows the break-even return. The new door's percent is how to calculate cash-on-cash return, and the monthly stack under it is rental property cash flow.

Last reviewed: November 2026. Educational only, not financial or tax advice.

Short answer

Compare the payment you would stop making, times 12, divided by the loan balance, against the new deal's cash-on-cash return. In our example, paying off $60,000 at 5.5% frees $490 a month, while a new $200,000 rental at 7% with 25% down nets about minus $16.

At today's rates, paying off often wins for monthly cash flow. Buying wins when you can find deals that beat the payoff yield.

The two numbers that matter

Each option turns the same cash into monthly cash flow, so compare them on the same scale. A higher story does not beat a higher deposit if the deposit is what you are trying to live on.

If the money for the next rental would come from a line of credit instead of savings, add its cost to the comparison. The HELOC payment calculator shows the draw payment, the repayment payment, and what a 2 point rate rise does.

  1. Payoff cash flow yield = monthly payment you stop making x 12 / loan balance. This is how much new cash flow each dollar buys when it kills the loan.
  2. New deal cash-on-cash = new rental's net monthly cash flow x 12 / total cash you put in (down payment, closing costs, and repairs).

One more number keeps you honest: the interest rate on the loan you would pay off. That is the interest you stop paying. Part of the payoff cash flow is just principal you were already paying to yourself, so the yield looks better than the true return. Principal is a savings account disguised as a victory lap.

Back to top

Quick calculator

The calculator compares the cash flow you free by paying off the loan with the cash flow of the next rental. Nothing is saved or sent anywhere, so a losing comparison can stay between you and the screen.

The loan you could pay off
020
-50005000

Need the new deal's real net first? Run it in the rental calculator or the cash-on-cash calculator. A guessed net is how the exciting door wins an argument it did not earn.

Back to top

Example 1: 5.5% loan vs a new rental at 7% (labeled hypothetical)

Paying off this older loan beats buying the new house on monthly cash flow. Example only, not a recommendation. Say an example landlord named Ren owes $60,000 at 5.5% with 15 years left, and the payment (principal and interest) is about $490 a month.

  • Pay it off: $490 a month of new cash flow. That is a 9.8% cash flow yield on $60,000, and 5.5% interest you no longer pay.
  • Buy another: a $200,000 house with $50,000 down plus $10,000 closing and repairs. The $150,000 loan at 7% for 30 years costs about $998 a month. Rent is $1,800. After $350 for tax and insurance, and 5% vacancy, 8% repairs, 5% capex, and 8% management, net is about minus $16 a month.

At today's rates, plenty of ordinary deals barely break even with 25% down. The new house can still win on appreciation, principal paydown, and depreciation. If the goal is monthly cash flow to retire on, paying off the 5.5% loan wins this matchup by about $500 a month. Ren does not get to spend the appreciation at the grocery store.

Back to top

Example 2: 3% loan vs a cash-flowing deal (labeled hypothetical)

A cheap loan can lose the payoff contest when the next deal actually cash flows. Example only, not a recommendation. Same made-up landlord, now owing $60,000 at 3% with 20 years left, and the payment is about $333 a month.

  • Pay it off: $333 a month. Cash flow yield 6.7%, but the interest you stop paying is only 3%. Cheap debt is hard to beat by paying it off.
  • Buy another: if you find a deal that really nets $400 a month on $60,000 in (8% cash-on-cash) after honest expenses, buying wins on cash flow and keeps the cheap loan working for you.

The rule of thumb that falls out: pay off high-rate debt, keep low-rate debt, and only buy when the new deal clearly beats the payoff yield after stress tests. Cheap debt is not a personality. It is a rate you can read on the statement.

Back to top

When each one makes sense

Payoff fits when the rate is high or the paycheck is about to disappear. Buying fits when the existing loan is cheap and the next deal beats that payoff yield after honest costs.

Lean toward paying off

  • The loan rate is 6% or higher.
  • You are within a few years of quitting and want the lowest possible monthly gap.
  • You cannot find deals that cash flow after real expenses.
  • One vacancy or a roof would stress your budget. No payment means no foreclosure risk.

Lean toward buying more

  • Your existing loan is cheap (under about 4.5%).
  • You still have a paycheck to absorb surprises.
  • The new deal beats your payoff yield after vacancy, repairs, capex, and management.
  • You have 6 months of expenses per door in reserves after the purchase.

The middle path

Many investors buy while working, then switch to paying down debt in the last 3 to 5 years before quitting. A partial payoff does not lower the payment on most mortgages unless you ask the lender to recast the loan. Extra principal on a 30-year loan is not the same as a 15-year loan: the 15 vs 30 year mortgage calculator shows the payoff month, the interest saved, and what the payment gap is worth if you invest it. Sending extra principal without a recast is a quieter loan, not a smaller payment.

Cash you pull out to buy another door has a cost above the new note rate, and the cash out refinance calculator is where that cost shows up.

Back to top

FAQ

The choice is a comparison of yields, not a character test. These answers stay with the cash.

Should I pay off my rental property early?

If the rate is high or retirement is close, often yes. If the rate is low and a new deal beats the payoff yield, buying usually grows cash flow faster. The rate on the statement matters more than the urge to be debt-free.

What return do I get from paying off a rental mortgage?

The interest you stop paying equals the loan rate. The cash flow yield is the freed payment x 12 / balance, which is higher because it includes principal. Do not brag about the bigger percent without saying the principal is in there.

Is it better to have one paid-off rental or two with mortgages?

Two financed rentals have more upside and more risk. One paid-off rental has steadier cash flow. Compare the net monthly cash flow and the worst-case month for each before the second set of keys feels like progress.

Does paying off a rental increase my taxes?

Usually a little, because mortgage interest was a deductible expense. Depreciation still shelters part of the income. A tax pro can tell you whether "a little" is actually annoying in your bracket.

How many rentals do I need before I start paying them off?

Work backward from the spending gap. The door-count version is how many rentals to retire. There is no trophy number of doors that suddenly makes payoff correct.

Back to top

Educational only. Not financial or tax advice. Hypothetical examples are labeled. Nothing here guarantees rents, occupancy, or returns. Run your own numbers.